Just a few of my own nominations:
"Day After Day", Badfinger
"Without You", written by Badfinger, as performed by Harry Nilsson
"Just Like Starting Over", John Lennon
"Moments in Love", the Art of Noise (no real lyrics, but great music)
"In Thee", Blue Oyster Cult
"Rain on Me", Jane Wiedlin
"Reasons for Waiting", Jethro Tull
"True Love Ways", Buddy Holly
"Think About It", Acoustic Junction
"Then I Met You", the Proclaimers
"Heaven on a Sunday", Paul McCartney
"I Will Hold On", Moxy Fruvous
"The Last Beat of My Heart", Siouxsie and the Banshees
"You're My Best Friend", Queen
"Fish on the Sand", George Harrison
"Let My Love Open the Door", Pete Townshend
"Hit the Parade", Something Happens
"Message to My Girl", Split Enz
"I've Been Waiting", Matthew Sweet
"All I Want", Toad the Wet Sprocket
Anyone care to try to pin down my musical tastes?
