I had considered both possibilities. One thing I left out was that it would only start doing that after a few minutes. That's long enough that raised some questions about it being her getting stretched. I still don't know what to do. All I can do is wait, She only gets in the anal mode occasionally, which I can understand with her experience thus far.

I was thinking about eating her out to the point that she's dripping cum and then mix that with my saliva and lube up her ass that way. Either that or in the shower. I figure if she's so horny she can't see straight, it'll make it easier for her to get past any bad feelings.

Any thoughts