Pixies Place Forums

Pixies Place Forums (http://www.pixies-place.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Chat (http://www.pixies-place.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=3)
-   -   A Pride Regained (http://www.pixies-place.com/forums/showthread.php?t=21566)

Grumble 08-06-2004 07:02 PM

I am like Sharni, I have always considered a priviledge to vote and always take the opportunity to do so. Local council elections are not compulsary and a 30% turnout is considered good.

The idea that people may not know what they are voting for is virtually a moot question really. The ones that vote in the USA would be mainly polarised voters who support a party and they would vote for that party regardless if the other had better policies.

Belial 08-08-2004 05:57 AM

I don't agree that compulsory voting is an essential part of the democratic process nor that it necessarily affords one a say in the running of the country.

Compulsory voting requires one to endorse a candidates, or in preferential systems, endorse multiple candidates to different degrees. When there are no suitable candidates (in the voter's eyes), the voter must endorse a candidate they do not support. I would much rather the option of offering no candidate my support if I do not wish to do so.

Saying that every voter gets a say in the running of the country assumes that there is a candidate(s) agreeing with the voter on how the country should be run. Let's say, for example, that I believe funding to higher education should be increased, however, no candidate has any commitment to do so. What say do I have in the running of the country, at least as far as this single issue is concerned? What if I find that on all the issues that matter to me, no candidate adequately represents me? Am I to vote against my own views?

To me it's like being locked in a room with a drink vending machine, and you can't leave until you've had a drink. What is there for the voter that sees Coke, Pepsi, Fanta, Sprite, and says "fuck that, if there's no water I'll pass"?

Catch22 08-08-2004 08:37 AM

At my age one is always passing water! :)

Irish 08-08-2004 11:04 AM

After the fiasco,over my last post,I wasn't going to post anymore,but I have to give an example.My wife & I,have many times voted,for what we considered,the best of two evils.There is also always,a spot,to write in another name.To think that your vote doesn't count,is alot of crap!
Ex:We,technically,live in Barrington NH.My property,is on the border of Barrington & Rochester.A FEW yrs ago,Barrington had no kindergarden.Our
oldest daughter thought that her kids,would benifit from a kindergarden.She
bugged,my wife & I,her sister & husband & her husband,to vote for kindergarden,in the next election.(Town)Kindergarden passed by 12 votes.
My wife & I,=2,youngest daughter & husband=2,Oldest daughter & husband =
2. 2+2+2=6.That's 1/2 of the passing votes,so don't tell me that individual
votes,don't count! Irish

lakritze 08-08-2004 12:23 PM

The only prefix I would like to see in front of Democracy is Participatory.In order for it to work,Democracy needs everybody's participation and not just in the voting booth.We don't have to agree on everything everytime. There is plenty of room for differences.But I believe the long road to putting Bush in the White House began with the realization that less than half of the people bother to vote.

Sharni 08-08-2004 06:33 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Irish
My wife & I,have many times voted,for what we considered,the best of two evils.To think that your vote doesn't count,is alot of crap!


Exactly!!

If you think that a polition will ever come along with ALL your views as his policies...sorry but your living in a fantasy world

You make the best of what you DO have to chose from

Belial 08-08-2004 06:39 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sharni
Exactly!!

If you think that a polition will ever come along with ALL your views as his policies...sorry but your living in a fantasy world

You make the best of what you DO have to chose from


Like I said, some people find that NO candidate represents ANY of their views on important issues...not that none of them represent ALL their views.

How do you make the best of that situation?

Belial 08-08-2004 06:42 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Irish
After the fiasco,over my last post,I wasn't going to post anymore,but I have to give an example.My wife & I,have many times voted,for what we considered,the best of two evils.There is also always,a spot,to write in another name.To think that your vote doesn't count,is alot of crap!
Ex:We,technically,live in Barrington NH.My property,is on the border of Barrington & Rochester.A FEW yrs ago,Barrington had no kindergarden.Our
oldest daughter thought that her kids,would benifit from a kindergarden.She
bugged,my wife & I,her sister & husband & her husband,to vote for kindergarden,in the next election.(Town)Kindergarden passed by 12 votes.
My wife & I,=2,youngest daughter & husband=2,Oldest daughter & husband =
2. 2+2+2=6.That's 1/2 of the passing votes,so don't tell me that individual
votes,don't count! Irish


Many elections are on a slightly larger scale. If a particular candidate wins, does it matter whether they win by a landslide, or a close call?

Sharni 08-08-2004 06:48 PM

Depends if your the winner or the loser i spose *L*

Sharni 08-08-2004 06:49 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Belial
Like I said, some people find that NO candidate represents ANY of their views on important issues...not that none of them represent ALL their views.

How do you make the best of that situation?


Again....you make the best of what you DO have to choose from

Belial 08-08-2004 06:55 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sharni
Again....you make the best of what you DO have to choose from


How?

You have x candidates and they're all on an equally bad footing. Do you roll dice?

Sharni 08-08-2004 07:00 PM

*sigh* do you have issues with making any decisions in real life?

Ya weigh all their pros and cons....then ya choose the ones i'd prefer in power...easy really

Belial 08-08-2004 07:40 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sharni
*sigh* do you have issues with making any decisions in real life?


Well usually when I make decisions in real life there exist choices where I stand to benefit.

Quote:
Originally Posted by sharni
[colur=blue]
Ya weigh all their pros and cons....then ya choose the ones i'd prefer in power...easy really[/color]


How do you weigh say 5 cons against 5 cons against 5 cons against...(etc)?

Sharni 08-08-2004 07:56 PM

*LOL*...i'd have thought that just a simple....

Ya pick the best cons outta em all...Ok example

Your given a choice: Die in your sleep...or....Die in a horrific painful accident?

I dont wanna die period but i have to make a choice.

For me the lesser of the two CONS is To die in my sleep....so that would be my choice...simple

Ya make a choice the best you can with whats been offered you!!

Belial 08-08-2004 08:02 PM

Quote:
Originally Posted by Sharni
*LOL*...i'd have thought that just a simple....

Ya pick the best cons outta em all...Ok example

Your given a choice: Die in your sleep...or....Die in a horrific painful accident?

I dont wanna die period but i have to make a choice.

For me the lesser of the two CONS is To die in my sleep....so that would be my choice...simple

Ya make a choice the best you can with whats been offered you!!


It's not the same thing.

Dying is inevitable. Voting is only inevitable because a few people decided it should be so.

I wasn't referring to the candidates themselves as cons. What I meant is, say I take into consideration 5 important issues when deciding who to vote for. If all candidates disagree with me on all 5 issues, they all have 0 pros and 5 cons, so there's no seperating them.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:39 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.0.10
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.