Lilith
04-27-2009, 09:23 PM
(FWM)
Woman is given Asbo against noisy sex ... but lasts just two days before breaching it
By PAUL SIMS
A woman who was given an Asbo banning her from making too much noise during sex has been arrested by police for breaching the order - just two days after it was imposed.
Caroline Cartwright was served the anti-social behaviour order on Friday after magistrates found her guilty of breaking an initial noise abatement order.
But by Sunday the 47-year-old had already breached the terms of her Asbo and was arrested by police officers.
For crying out loud: Caroline Cartwright says sex with husband Steve, left, is no louder than average and the couple won't be silenced
Today she remained defiant and, despite a second arrest yesterday and the threat of prison, she vowed to carry on with her love life.
'I'm not going to stop,' she said. 'I've been making the same noises since the Asbo was imposed, and this morning, we were making noises for three hours.
'I can't stop making noise during sex, it's unnatural to not make any noises, and I don't think that I'm particularly loud.'
Mrs Cartwright said she would be appealing against the four-year Asbo and her conviction for breaching the noise abatement order.
The Asbo - imposed after police received 25 complaints from neighbours - bans her from 'making excessive noise' during love-making with husband Steve.
Magistrates heard that the couple's neighbour Margery Ball had not had a decent night's sleep in two years because of the noise made by the pair - even though she is partially deaf.
After receiving complaints environmental health officers placed recording equipment in the flat next door to her house in Concord, Tyne and Wear.
Another neighbour, Rachel O'Connor, pressed a button on the machine every time she was disturbed by noise from next door.
She told Sunderland Magistrates Court: 'I heard sounds of a sexual nature. They were really loud, and there was a lot of moaning and groaning and screaming as if in pain.
'It wasn't just the woman, it came from both parties.'
Miss O'Connor told the court that when she first moved into the flat, in November 2007, the noise started at midnight and lasted until 3am.
Now, she said, the noise started at about 6.30am and lasted until 9am.
Environmental Health officer Pamela Spark told the court she had listened to 23 recordings of the couple having sex.
She said: 'There was an excessive screaming female voice on the recordings.'
As well as being given an Asbo, Mrs Cartwright was fined £200 with £300 costs. She will next appear before Houghton Magistrates on Monday accused of breaching the Asbo.
Woman is given Asbo against noisy sex ... but lasts just two days before breaching it
By PAUL SIMS
A woman who was given an Asbo banning her from making too much noise during sex has been arrested by police for breaching the order - just two days after it was imposed.
Caroline Cartwright was served the anti-social behaviour order on Friday after magistrates found her guilty of breaking an initial noise abatement order.
But by Sunday the 47-year-old had already breached the terms of her Asbo and was arrested by police officers.
For crying out loud: Caroline Cartwright says sex with husband Steve, left, is no louder than average and the couple won't be silenced
Today she remained defiant and, despite a second arrest yesterday and the threat of prison, she vowed to carry on with her love life.
'I'm not going to stop,' she said. 'I've been making the same noises since the Asbo was imposed, and this morning, we were making noises for three hours.
'I can't stop making noise during sex, it's unnatural to not make any noises, and I don't think that I'm particularly loud.'
Mrs Cartwright said she would be appealing against the four-year Asbo and her conviction for breaching the noise abatement order.
The Asbo - imposed after police received 25 complaints from neighbours - bans her from 'making excessive noise' during love-making with husband Steve.
Magistrates heard that the couple's neighbour Margery Ball had not had a decent night's sleep in two years because of the noise made by the pair - even though she is partially deaf.
After receiving complaints environmental health officers placed recording equipment in the flat next door to her house in Concord, Tyne and Wear.
Another neighbour, Rachel O'Connor, pressed a button on the machine every time she was disturbed by noise from next door.
She told Sunderland Magistrates Court: 'I heard sounds of a sexual nature. They were really loud, and there was a lot of moaning and groaning and screaming as if in pain.
'It wasn't just the woman, it came from both parties.'
Miss O'Connor told the court that when she first moved into the flat, in November 2007, the noise started at midnight and lasted until 3am.
Now, she said, the noise started at about 6.30am and lasted until 9am.
Environmental Health officer Pamela Spark told the court she had listened to 23 recordings of the couple having sex.
She said: 'There was an excessive screaming female voice on the recordings.'
As well as being given an Asbo, Mrs Cartwright was fined £200 with £300 costs. She will next appear before Houghton Magistrates on Monday accused of breaching the Asbo.